Showing posts with label 2008 NFL Predictions. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 2008 NFL Predictions. Show all posts

Saturday, February 21, 2009

Accountability: Revisiting My 2008 NFL Predictions

Throughout the NFL offseason I submitted my predictions for how the 2008 NFL season would shake out. Now here I am, with the 2008 NFL season almost a month over, back to take a look at how wrong I was.

As expected, there were some hits and misses. You can look at my first and second version of the predictions but I'll be comparing them with my last predicted standings, submitted at the end of August. Let's get to it.

Click the above image for my prediction comparisons.

OK so I guess I'll start with the good. I nailed Buffalo (7-9), Oakland (5-11), Minnesota (10-6), and Tampa Bay (9-7). I was a mere Eagles win over Cincinnati away from hitting both of those teams, though I was off by 1/2 for both of them because of the tie. Did you know that could happen in the NFL? Anyway, I was also off by only one game with the Colts, Texans, Patriots, Jets, Broncos, Chiefs, Redskins, and Cardinals. I said the Eagles and Colts would be wild card teams, which they were, and had the Vikings, Steelers, and Chargers winning their divisions.

Unfortunately there's more. It's all bad too. Neither of my predicted teams made the Super Bowl. Actually, neither even made the playoffs. Yuck. I also predicted the final record of 11 teams incorrect by five or more wins! That's uuuugggggllllllyyyyyy!!!! I have no alibi.

Think I did bad? Well I wasn't alone. Check out Gregg Easterbrook's Bad Predictions Review at ESPNs Page 2.

I hope to do a bit better next year.

Not likely.

Friday, September 12, 2008

Madden 09 1-season Simulation Results

I am simulating the current NFL season using Madden 09 as a simulation engine, as I did for the 2008-2009 NCAA Football season (1-season results, 10-simulation average results). ESPN Video Games does this on a weekly basis for marquee college games and every NFL game. I am taking it a step farther and doing this all at one time, at an attempt to predict what will happen this season.

I have waited until after week 1 to get the latest Madden 09 roster update, released today. Here are the guidelines so you can understand how this data was obtained:

  • Rosters - I used the latest roster update available from EA (released on 9/12/2008). This includes a few ratings bumps and players transferred to IR, most notably Tom Brady. I only tweaked a few parts of the rosters. I added a few free agents to their respective teams that EA overlooked (i.e. Eddie Kennison to the Rams, Chris Simms to the Titans). This should have little - if any - impact on the results but it is a more realistic interpretation of the current rosters. NO PLAYERS ATTRIBUTES WERE CHANGED.
  • Injuries - Since this is a simulation (as in there are no games played by a human), I turned off the sim. injuries when starting the franchise. Therefore no one gets injured as the season plays out. I am leaving the preexisting injuries on so, like I said, no Tom Brady for New England.
  • Simulation Start - Each sim. will begin in week 1. The franchise is saved after the preseason so that any players signed by the teams remains constant throughout each simulation. Teams did sign some available free agents though their impact is minor, if any.
OK so there are my guidelines. This post shows only a 1-season simulation. The 10-sim conglomerate will be coming in the next few days. So what does Madden 09 believe will happen during this NFL season? Take a look...

Team

Conference

Division

Wins

Losses

Baltimore Ravens

AFC

North

8

8

Cincinnati Bengals

AFC

North

3

13

Cleveland Browns

AFC

North

5

11

Pittsburgh Steelers

AFC

North

11

5

Houston Texans

AFC

South

9

7

Indianapolis Colts

AFC

South

12

4

Jacksonville Jaguars

AFC

South

12

4

Tennessee Titans

AFC

South

7

9

Buffalo Bills

AFC

East

9

7

Miami Dolphins

AFC

East

4

12

New England Patriots

AFC

East

6

10

New York Jets

AFC

East

8

8

Denver Broncos

AFC

West

4

12

Kansas City Chiefs

AFC

West

9

7

Oakland Raiders

AFC

West

6

10

San Diego Chargers

AFC

West

10

6

Chicago Bears

NFC

North

8

8

Detroit Lions

NFC

North

6

10

Green Bay Packers

NFC

North

6

10

Minnesota Vikings

NFC

North

9

7

Atlanta Falcons

NFC

South

6

9

Carolina Panthers

NFC

South

10

6

New Orleans Saints

NFC

South

6

9

Tampa Bay Buccaneers

NFC

South

12

4

Dallas Cowboys

NFC

East

7

9

New York Giants

NFC

East

5

11

Philadelphia Eagles

NFC

East

13

3

Washington Redskins

NFC

East

9

7

Arizona Cardinals

NFC

West

7

9

San Francisco 49ers

NFC

West

11

5

Seattle Seahawks

NFC

West

7

9

St. Louis Rams

NFC

West

10

6


Not too ridiculous. The 49ers winning the West is probably the only thing you can definitely say won't happen. Dallas looked like a team that is much better than 7-9. Denver is better than 4-12, too. The Falcons and Saints tied a game that's why the are both 6-9, they were actually 6-9-1. OK so who made it to Super Bowl XLIII?

We have the first instance of a team playing a Super Bowl in front of a home crowd. The Tampa Bay Buccaneers made it to the 43rd Super Bowl, played at Raymond James Stadium, their very own stadium. The Jacksonville Jaguars made it an all-Florida matchup. And the home team emerged victorious. The Buccaneers dismissed the Jaguars in a tight game, 35-27. Jeff Garcia was named MVP.

So there is a quick 1-season simulation. I'll have much more following the completion of 10-simulations. Stay tuned!

Tuesday, August 26, 2008

2008 NFL Predictions, Version 3: End of Training Camp

Well training camps are over and teams are into normal practice regiments preparing for the season opener, which is just over a week away. Team trotted out their healthy starters for 3 quarters of the most recent preseason games and they proved to enlighten the public on who's for real and who should be ready for 2009. My updated predictions reflect my feelings on how teams will perform based on training camps and preseason games. Weaknesses have been exposed and some have been fixed. How will the season play out? For the evolution of my predictions, refer to version 1 and 2.


AFC

North

Team

Win-Loss

Δ Win-Loss

Notes

Steelers

10-6

±0

Browns

9-7

-1

Ravens

6-10

±0

Bengals

5-11

±0

South

Team

Win-Loss

Δ Win-Loss

Notes

Jaguars

11-5

±0

Colts

11-5

±0

Wild Card

Titans

7-9

-1

Texans

7-9

+1

East

Team

Win-Loss

Δ Win-Loss

Notes

Patriots

12-4

±0

Jets

10-6

+1

Wild Card

Bills

7-9

±0

Dolphins

6-10

±0

West

Team

Win-Loss

Δ Win-Loss

Notes

Chargers

11-5

-2

Broncos

7-9

±0

Raiders

5-11

±0

Chiefs

3-13

±0

NFC

North

Team

Win-Loss

Δ Win-Loss

Notes

Vikings

10-6

±0

Packers

9-7

-1

Lions

7-9

+1

Bears

3-13

-1

South

Team

Win-Loss

Δ Win-Loss

Notes

Saints

11-5

+1

Panthers

10-6

+1

Wild Card

Buccaneers

9-7

±0

Falcons

5-11

+2

East

Team

Win-Loss

Δ Win-Loss

Notes

Cowboys

12-4

+1

Eagles

10-6

±0

Wild Card

Redskins

7-9

-2

Giants

7-9

±0

West

Team

Win-Loss

Δ Win-Loss

Notes

Seahawks

9-7

±0

Cardinals

8-8

±0

Rams

7-9

±0

49ers

5-11

±0


2008-2009 NFL Playoffs

Wild Card Round

AFC

(6) Jets

(3) Chargers

(3) Chargers, 26-14

(5) Colts

(4) Steelers

(5) Colts, 27-17

NFC

(6) Eagles

(3) Vikings

(3) Vikings, 20-13

(5) Panthers

(4) Seahawks

(5) Panthers, 24-20

Divisional Round

AFC

(5) Colts

(1) Patriots

(1) Patriots, 31-30

(3) Chargers

(2) Jaguars

(2) Jaguars, 17-14

NFC

(5) Panthers

(1) Cowboys

(1) Cowboys, 38-20

(4) Vikings

(2) Saints

(2) Saints, 35-24

Conference Championships

AFC

(2) Jaguars

(1) Patriots

(2) Jaguars, 27-24

NFC

(2) Saints

(1) Cowboys

(1) Cowboys, 31-21

Super Bowl XLIII

Cowboys

Jaguars

Cowboys, 23-20


A lot has changed since version 2. The Browns have been dropped in the AFC North, mostly due to the difficult schedule they will face in the regular season and their inconsistency so far this preseason. The injury to Derek Anderson has revealed that Brady Quinn isn't ready, too. The Steelers are the Browns only threat as the Ravens and Bengals look like 5 or 6 win teams.

I have not liked the way the Titans have been playing. The lack of improvement by Vince Young has to be disappointing. The Titans may struggle this year. I still foresee a strong Jaguars team capable of toppling the Colts, who have injury problems of their own. Not only is Peyton Manning hobbled, the linebacker corp has been shredded and Bob Sanders and Dwight Freeney remain less than 100%.

The addition of Brett Favre to the Jets is capable of producing 1 more win but the Patriots will rule once again. I am not as high on the Bills as some are. Their line is porous, especially without Jason Peters. Rookie James Hardy has barely been on the field. Marshawn Lynch will see a lot of 8 man fronts until Trent Edwards opens up. The Dolphins will surprise some teams this year.

The Chargers are still the best team - hands down - in the west. The Chiefs showed me absolutely nothing against the Dolphins and they could be the worst team in the league this year. I've been saying that since the spring. Oakland is progressing and has a lot of talent but they need at least 1 more year. Denver is merely average. The Chargers drop has to do with some uninspired play thus far and some notable injuries. Losing Merriman for a few games will hurt but you also have to remember how bad Jamal Williams' knees are and the fact that offensive stars Antonio Gates, Philip Rivers, and LaDainian Tomlinson are all returning from injuries. Even without them though the Chargers are still better than anyone else in the West.

In the NFC I have liked what has been shown by the Lions. They are feisty and could be fighting for a wild card spot towards the end of the year. They must avoid a dreadful finish that crushed them last year. The Vikings have looked as I thought they would and should take the North division title. The Packers have been a little disappointing but I still have faith in Aaron Rodgers. The below average defensive line has me a tad worried, however. The Bears will be bad. They will fight with the Chiefs for the worst record in the league.

The Falcons may not be as bad as I originally thought. Their young players have shown improvement and Matt Ryan has performed admirably so far. They still won't compete in the South but they won't be a complete pushover like the Chiefs and Bears will be. The Panthers have look stronger than I originally thought, despite the lack of healthy receiving targets for Jake Delhomme. The new o-line and ground game will be a force. Watch out for them if Julius Peppers regains form. The Saints have a dynamic offense that has only gotten better. The defense, specifically the secondary, still concerns me. They will fight Carolina for the division title. I think the Buccaneers stumble a bit this year. Garcia is overrated and injury prone plus the ground game will suffer without Davin Joseph and Earnest Graham as the feature back.

The Cowboys look like the real deal and I definitely think Wade Phillips will get at least 1 playoff win this season. The Cowboys are the team to beat in the NFC. The Eagles are no pushover, especially if they perform the way they did against New England. Despite Kevin Curtis and Reggie Brown being sidelined the team looked good on offense. And they proved the defense is more than capable of stopping a Brady-less Patriots team. The Eagles will surprise a few teams this year, too. The Redskins looked awful against Carolina. I had some hopes for them but I really ahven't liked what I have seen. They are an average team but I don't think they have enough talent to grab a wild card spot. I have had the defending Super Bowl Champions in last place in ever version. Anyone think they won't finish there? Last year was more about luck and scheme than talent. The shceme will be countered this season and they lost some of the best talent they had. Michael Strahan retired and Osi Umenyiora was lost for the year. Eli Manning, depsite his play in the playoffs, is nowhere close to the level his brother is at. This could be a ver disappointing year for the Giants.

The west is division filled with mystery and mediocre teams. While I think the Seahawks hold on another year, examing their roster doesn't leave me feeling that great. The o-line has never recovered from the departure of Steve Hutchinson and Matt Hasselbeck and the receivers are battling injuries. Fortunately from them no competitors have stepped forward. The Cardinals seems tuck in neutral and the disastrous play of Matt Leinart recently may have shaken some confidence. I still think they are a .500 team with the ability to fight Seattle for the division title. The Rams will have a bit of resurgence this season. Last year was an anomaly for them. They have too much offensive firepower to finish 4-12. I really wouldn't be shocked if they challenged for the division title either. The only team I am really down on is San Francisco. There is talent on paper but it hasn't been utilized correctly. J.T. O'Sullivan is a great story but do you really think he is the answer at QB? Can he produce more than 4 or 5 wins? They may get to 6 but anything higher than that should give Mike Nolan another year. They are some key pieces away (top WR, stable QB) from being a competitive team.

So there it is, my 3rd set of predictions. I was hoping to do 4 but I think this may be my final version, pending any drastic changes to a team prior to September 4th. Let football season begin!!!